EW's Critics Agree!

Lisa Schwarzbaum:

Best:

1. Sideways

2. Million Dollar Baby

3. The Incredibles

4. Maria Full of Grace

5. Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless Mind

6. Moolaade

7. Collateral

8. The Aviator

9. The Return

10. Bright Leaves

Worst:

1. Spanglish

2. Surviving Christmas

3. Napoleon Dynamite

4. Ocean's Twelve

5. When Will I Be Loved



Owen Gleiberman:

Best:

1. Sideways

2. Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless Mind

3. The Incredibles

4. Maria Full of Grace

5. Kinsey

6. Before Sunset

7. Osama

8. Open Water

9. 13 Going on 30

10. Ray

Worst:

1. Dogville

2. She Hate Me

3. Taxi

4. Control Room

5. Van Helsing



Interesting, neither lists have Kill Bill: Vol. 2 on. This is the first time that I recall both critics having the same number 1 film of the year.